[From Healing the Harm, Section
One: "The Pollution Problems Created by Medical Waste"]
Mercury is a persistent, bioaccumulative
toxin that has been linked to numerous health effects in wildlife
and humans. Its natural state under ambient temperature is a silvery-white
liquid that changes easily from solid to liquid to gas, allowing
it to circulate in the atmosphere and the environment. There are
three major forms of mercury that circulate in the atmosphere
but the one of most concern for humans and wildlife is methylmercury,
because it builds up in the muscle tissue.
Health Effects
Mercury is a potent neurotoxin, which means
it attacks the body's central nervous system; it can also harm
the brain, kidneys and lungs. It can cross the blood-brain barrier
as well as the placenta. Neurotoxic risks to developing fetuses
and young children are primary reasons for fish-consumption advisories,
aimed at discouraging pregnant women, women of child-bearing age,
and young children from eating too much fish. Studies done on
women who ate methylmercury-contaminated fish or grain showed
that even when the mothers showed few effects of exposure, their
infants demonstrated nervous-system damage.
Symptoms of Mercury Poisoning:
* Impairment of the peripheral vision;
* Disturbances in sensations ("pins
and needles" feelings, numbness) usually in the hands feet
and sometimes around the mouth;
* Lack of coordination of movements, such
as writing;
* Impairment of speech, hearing, walking;
* Muscle weakness;
* Skin rashes;
* Mood swings;
* Memory loss;
* Mental disturbances.
Methylmercury has been shown to cause tumors
in mice at high doses. It is classified as a reproductive toxin,
because data indicate that methylmercury could increase the frequency
of mutation in human eggs and sperm. Methylmercury is also an
endocrine-disrupting chemical, impairing normal thyroid functions,
but these effects appear only at very high exposures.
Many animals are also affected by mercury.
Fish accumulate mercury in their muscle tissue. Animals which
rely on fish for a large portion of their diets, such as loons,
eagles, mink and osprey are at risk from contaminated fish and
may suffer neurological impairment as a result.
Exposure
Humans are most likely to be exposed to
mercury through the consumption of fish. Exposure can also take
place through the ingestion of water and other food sources and
through the skin. In some workplaces (such as in a health care
setting), there is also a risk of mercury inhalation.
Methylmercury accumulates in the environment
and in wildlife, but the highest concentrations appear in the
muscle tissue of fish, particularly fish at the top of the aquatic
food chain.
Measured values of methylmercury in fish
from various areas of the U.S. range from less than 0.1 parts
per million (ppm) to 8.94 ppm; typical values are between 0.11
and 0.26 ppm.
Tuna 0.206
Shrimp 0.047
Pollock 0.15
Salmon 0.035
Cod 0.121
Catfish 0.088 &.16
Clam 0.023
Flounder 0.092
Crab 0.117
Scallop 0.042
Source: MERCURY STUDY REPORT TO
CONGRESS, Volume I: Executive Summary, SAB Review draft, USEPA,
June 1996.
According to the US EPA, fish consumption
advisories for mercury increased 46% from 1993 to 1995 (899 to
1,308). The number of states that have mercury advisories has
risen steadily from 27 in 1993 to 37 in 1996. Ten states have
issued 90% of the 1,308 mercury advisories in effect: Minnesota,
Wisconsin, Florida, North Dakota, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Michigan,
New Mexico, South Carolina and Georgia.
Note that about one gram of mercury will
contaminate a twenty-acre lake with enough mercury to cause fish
advisories. For comparison, a teaspoon of mercury weighs about
70 grams. One thermostat contains about 3 grams of mercury, one
electrical switch about 3.5 grams of mercury, and 100 fluorescent
lamps contain about 4 grams of mercury.
Elemental mercury can be inhaled easily
and is readily absorbed into the bloodstream. This can occur when
an item containing elemental mercury (like a thermometer or a
sphygmomanometer) breaks, spilling the mercury into the open.
This type of exposure allows the mercury to penetrate the blood-brain
and placental barriers in humans and wildlife.
Another controversial source of human exposure
to mercury is dental amalgam. Amalgams, or mixtures, of mercury,
silver, copper and tin have been commonly used to fill cavities.
Studies have shown that mercury vapor is released from mercury
amalgam fillings.
The half-life of mercury, or the time needed
to excrete half of a dose to which one is exposed at any one time,
is 44 to 80 days. Mercury is excreted via feces, urine and breast
milk.
Where Does Mercury Pollution Come From?
Mercury has been widely used in many industrial
processes because of its diverse properties: it responds to temperature
and pressure changes (making it useful for thermometers and blood-pressure
devices), conducts electricity, and forms alloys with other metals.
Numerous studies show that mercury contamination of the environment
is taking place due to atmospheric transport and deposition of
mercury coming from incinerators. The Mercury Report to Congress
listed medical waste incinerators as the number-two emitter of
mercury.
Some Sources Of Mercury In Health Care
& Their Alternatives
Mercury is used in number of medical products.
The good news is that there are alternatives for most of those
items. The following is a list of some mercury-containing medical
products, and their safer counterparts:
| MERCURY-CONTAINING PRODUCT | REPLACEMENT |
| Thermometers | Geratherm, electronic battery-operated, range, infrared aural [ear], Enviro-safe Immersion |
| Weighted Esophageal dilator | Tungsten-weighted dilator |
| Feeding tubes | All plastic, tungsten-weighted |
| Immune saline with thimerosal (merthiolate) | Thimerosal-free saline |
| Mercurochrome | Neosporin, Mycin |
| Thimerosal | Thimerosal-free bactericides |
| Dental Amalgams | Non-mercury amalgams* |
| Batteries (for pagers, mobiles equipment, etc.) | Nickel-cadmium, other rechargeable batteries |
Sources: MERCURY IN THE HEALTH CARE
SECTOR: THE COST OF ALTERNATIVE PRODUCTS (Draft), Pollution Probe,
November 1996, p. 15. Personal Communication with Dr. Paul Kirkegaard,
DDS, St. Paul, MN, April 1997.
* It must be noted that one common alternative
dental amalgam contains Bisphenol A, an endocrine disrupting chemical.
However, there are other amalgams available which contain neither
mercury nor Bisphenol A.