Stop Toxic Debt!
In 1995, the Philippine Department of Health (DoH), responding to public criticism and negative coverage in the popular press regarding the improper disposal of infectious medical waste in the country, launched a project to improve the management of medical waste by DoH-controlled hospitals in the country.
Dubbed "The Austrian project for the establishment of waste disposal facilities and upgrading of the medical equipment standard in DoH hospitals," the project's key component was the purchase of 26 medical waste incinerators called Multizon, which were manufactured by Liechtenstein-based Hoval and were supplied to the DoH by VAMED, an Austrian company. The project was financed by a loan from Bank Austria Aktiengessellschaft.
The incinerators were distributed throughout the various DoH-controlled hospitals nationwide. However, within a couple of years of operation, the incinerators started eliciting complaints from various groups. In 1999, the Philippine legislature also passed the Clean Air Act, which banned the incineration of medical waste starting in 2003.
The DoH, in cooperation with the WHO, subjected the incinerators to a comprehensive emission test, the results of which showed egregiously high emissions. In one incinerator tested, dioxin emissions were eight hundred seventy times the limit set by the Clean Air Act.
The incinerators were shut down by the DoH in 2003, but the Philippines is allocating roughly US$2 million a year to pay for the loan connected with the failed project. The last payment is to fall due in 2014.
HCWH-Southeast Asia is leading the campaign to cancel the Austrian loan connected with the medical waste incinerators. See the report, Toxic Debt: The Onerous Austrian Legacy of Medical Waste in the Philippines.
Key Resources
- Best Environmental Practices and Alternative Technologies for Medical Waste Management (pdf) Discusses impacts of medical waste incineration and alternatives for the developing world
- Best Practices in Health Care Waste Management: Examples from Four Philippine Hospitals
- British Society for Ecological Medicine Report: Health Effects of Waste Incinerators (pdf)
- Contamination of Chicken Eggs near the Queen Mary's Hospital, Lucknow Medical Waste Incinerator in Uttar Pradesh (India) by Dioxins, PCBs and Hexachlorobenzene
- Eleven Recommendations for Improving Health Care Waste Management (pdf)
- For Proper Disposal: A Global Inventory of Alternative Medical Waste Treatment Technologies (pdf)
- Health Care Waste Assessment Project: A Partnership Between the Local Government Unit of Baguio, Tertiary Hospitals in Baguio City and Health Care Without Harm-Southeast Asia (pdf)
- Health Care Waste Assessment Tools (pdf)
- Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives (GAIA) website
- Global Environment Facility (GEF) Project
- Global Environment Facility website
- Ground Work: Community Action to Reduce the Harm Caused by Health Care Waste and Incineration in South Africa
- ICN Position Statement: Medical Waste, Role of Nurses and Nursing (pdf)
- Greenpeace Report: Incineration and Human Health: State of Knowledge of the Impacts of Waste Incinerators on Human Health (pdf)
- Non-Incineration Medical Waste Treatment Technologies in Europe (2004 version, pdf)
- Preventing Needlestick Injuries among Healthcare Workers: A WHO-ICN Collaboration (pdf)
- Tanzania's project to replace an incinerator with a safer, non-burn waste treatment system (pdf)
- Testing a Waste Treament Autoclave at a Hospital in Tanzania: A Technical Brief (pdf)
- Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants website
- Toxics Link Training Manual Understanding and Simplifying Bio-Medical Waste Management (pdf)
- WHO Aide-Memoire for a Strategy to Protect Health Workers from Infection with Bloodborne Viruses (pdf)
- WHO Assessment of Small-Scale Incinerators for Health Care Waste (pdf)
- WHO Core Principles for Achieving Safe and Sustainable Management of Health-Care Waste (pdf)
- WHO Expanded Costing Analysis Tools (ECAT) for Health Care Waste Management
- WHO Safe Health-Care Waste Management Policy Paper (pdf)
- WHO Safe Management of Wastes from Healthcare Activities

